Mutual Aid

Diversity in the fire service isn't just about race — it's about ideas

 

By Duane Dodwell

Many thoughts occured to me when asked what fire chiefs need to be mindful of now and in the future. But one word that continually stood out in my mind was "inclusion."

The catalyst for my entry into the fire service was the result of affirmative-action plans, consent decrees, and other legal issues that still plague the service today. These efforts obviously changed the face of the fire service "diversity"; however, they also left a trail of anger, resentment and other such emotions that have left an indelible mark.

But now as a result of legal action, fear, and failure to act, we have been moving backward to a more homogenous environment — especially at the highest levels of organizational leadership. We also have been failing to focus on "inclusion" of all as a means to move organizations forward.

Although the fire service is incorporating formal education, credentialing, and other forms of high level training into job or position requirements, we still fail at the basic level of ensuring that we have representation at the table where the "real" decisions are being made about how organizations can, should, and will move forward. It's all fine and well that we discuss the issue of inclusion; but if you don't act, your words are meaningless.

From my perspective, inclusion of people, thoughts, ideas, and concepts is the key to moving the profession forward; as one of my colleagues pointed out in a presentation recently, "if we don't change, we will die." It sounds a bit extreme, but failure to move forward will keep us in the past, and although we have had success in the past, we don't want our failures to exceed those successes.

So, as new and recycled fire chiefs want to be successful now and in the future, I think it is imperative that despite their political beliefs, they need to reflect back on what just happened in our presidential election — diversity and ethnicity are key factors in placing people in positions of power and authority, and inclusion is an important factor that cannot be overlooked.

Discuss this Blog Entry 3

Anonymous (not verified)
on Jan 19, 2013

I have been a fireman for 22 yrs. In all those years I have never had someone say they wanted me because of my diversity. They called 911 and new that the best there was to offer was responding. Not by color, religious background, etc., but by merit. If you hire in as a number, the best PERSON for the job will emerge. Yes I was discriminated against because off the color of my skin and my gender but I did not let that take away my desire to serve others. I found a dept that did not want an employee just because of this color or that. They began the process with every candidate being EQUAL and you were hired as the result of passing the required testr ahead of the next person. What an idea....straight forward competition and not anything else.

chiefbobr
on Jan 21, 2013

Exclusion of people for reasons of race, creed, religious belief or gender was and is wrong, and very few would disagree with that. The fire service as a profession, along with many other professions and businesses in the nation, went through those battles in the 1970's and 80' and I would agree that some resentment remains to this day. But I take exception to the general premise of this article that significant progress hasn't been made and that we as a profession are in fact moving backward.

From my perspective, most modern fire service organizations today are progressive and do everything that they can to recruit, hire, and promote minorities. The challenge comes when a few (and it's usually a very few) dissatisfied minority employees don't want to achieve promotions and work their way up the old-fashioned way and chose to go the legal route with lawsuits and EEO complaints instead.

That approach may win headlines and in some cases actually gain a few promotions, but at what cost ? If a person truly believes that he or she has been discriminated against in hiring or promotions and if he or she has exhausted all of the internal remidies (HR complaints, union grievances, etc) available, then I would agree that a lawsuit or an EEO complaint would probably be the only recourse and would be justifiable. Otherwise, the applicant or candidate needs to go back to square one and better prepare him or herself for the next opportunity.

I think the bottom line here as that our nation as a whole and the fire service in general is becoming much more diverse and inclusive, and that's a good thing (the author and I agree here). Diversity and inclusion is occuring in the higher ranks of the fire service as well, though maybe not fast enough to satisfy some people. My suggestion would be to continually review the system to insure fairness for everyone regardless of race, color, creed or gender and then let it work; to do otherwise is a slap in the face to the thousands of so-called 'minorities' in the fire service who have done just that and gained the respect of all of their peers in the process.

muzammali
on May 18, 2013

I have been absent for some time, but now I remember why I used to love this website. Thank you, I'll try and check back more often. How frequently you update your web site?
---------------------
http://www.blogg.org/blog-104845.html

Please or Register to post comments.

What's Mutual Aid?

Mutual Aid is a blog of news and views from FIRE CHIEF staff and industry experts -- a virtual conversation about the issues important to you.

Contributors

Janet Wilmoth

Janet Wilmoth grew up in a family of firefighters in a Chicago suburb. She first worked for FIRE CHIEF magazine in 1986 as an associate editor and also served as FIRE CHIEF's international...

Mary Rose Roberts

Mary Rose Roberts is a senior editor at Penton Media, with a focus on wireless technology, public safety and fire leadership for FIRE CHIEF, Urgent Communications and Wildfire magazines. She also...
Blog Archive